Areas of Interest: Church Life & Practice, Faith & Culture, Futures of the Church

The Future of Innovation (Driver 4): Precarious Ambivalence

Futures Research Brief
5 - minutes to engage
Topics: Christian Leaders, Church Leaders, Denominational Leaders

Future of Innovation

“Innovation is future-directed activity, focused on making the future real today, if by ever so little. Innovation, in whatever way we try to do it, is an attempt to open up today to the future, if by ever so little. At the same time, the future of anything, including innovation, is unknowable” (Rehn, 2023, p. 388) 

Over the coming months, we will be sharing findings and insights from our most recent major research initiative a national project is titled The Future of Innovation. 

The Future of Innovation is a research and sensemaking initiative exploring how innovation is changing across the Canadian Christian landscape, and what it could look like as we move toward the year 2040. 

In the weeks ahead, we will introduce five research-based compound drivers shaping the conditions for innovation in Canada today. These drivers do not describe specific programs or quick solutions. Rather, they name deeper structural and cultural forces influencing innovation over time. 

The five compound drivers are: 

  • The Rise of Network-Oriented Ecosystems 
  • Diminished Imagination 
  • Augmented Innovation 
  • Precarious Ambivalence 
  • Constraining Instability 

Research briefs such as this one will be released over the next five weeks, with the full research, theological reflection, practitioner stories, and in-depth analysis published in The Future of Innovation: Interpretive Field Guide, being released on April 27th.

This interpretive field guide is not a strategy manual. It is designed to help leaders read their context more clearly and discern more intentionally. The guide highlights signals of change, patterns, theological reflection, and national perspectives toward the future of innovation that is intended to strengthens imagination and shared understanding. 

This initiative will culminate in a free online national gathering on May 4th. This gathering will provide space for leaders across denominations, organizations, and churches to contextualize what these shifts mean for their own setting, while hearing from other leaders.

We hope you will join us as we explore, imagine, and faithfully discern what the future of innovation could look like for Canadian Christians. 

Driver of Change #4

Compressed Discernment: Innovation in an Age of Polarization and Constant Attention 

What’s Changing 

Christian leaders are increasingly required to respond to complex and contested issues before they have time to think them through. 

Digital media, social platforms, and polarized public conversations constantly surface difficult questions (about theology, culture, justice, technology, identity, and belonging) and present them as urgent and binary. Leaders are often expected to signal where they stand quickly: for or against, faithful or compromised, courageous or out of touch. 

In this environment, the ability to hold tension thoughtfully is squeezed out. Instead of being worked through over time, tension becomes unstable. Leaders are pushed to swing between responses, rush to decisions just to relieve pressure, fall back on familiar patterns, or step away from innovation altogether. Innovation takes shape in this unsettled space, often before leaders have the time or support to reflect or hold competing goods together. 

Why This Matters for Ministry Leaders 

When discernment is compressed, innovation changes shape. 

Rather than emerging from careful reflection, innovation is often driven by reaction, responding to the loudest voices, strongest emotions, or most visible pressures. Leaders may adopt initiatives, language, or positions to demonstrate responsiveness, even when deeper questions remain unresolved. 

This makes it harder to sit with uncertainty, listen across difference, or integrate theology, context, and experience over time. Thoughtfulness can be mistaken for avoidance, and patience for lack of conviction. As a result, innovation can become polarized, brittle, or short-lived—moving quickly but lacking depth or durability. 

Over time, leaders may either overcommit to visible innovation as a form of signaling or disengage altogether to avoid missteps. In both cases, innovation is shaped more by attention dynamics than by wisdom formed through discernment. 

Signals Behind the Shift 

  • Attention-driven environments: Complex issues are surfaced suddenly and repeatedly, framed as urgent and emotionally charged. 
  • Polarization: Innovation choices are quickly moralized, leaving little room for provisional learning or exploration. 
  • Public visibility of leadership: Leaders’ responses are increasingly observed, shared, and judged beyond their local context. 
  • Algorithmic amplification: Strong positions travel farther than careful reflection.
  • Fewer shared spaces for discernment: Trusted forums for slow, communal reflection are increasingly rare. 

Together, these forces compress the time and space needed for thoughtful innovation. 

An Invitation 

This brief names one compound driver shaping the future of Christian innovation in Canada. The Future of Innovation: Interpretive Field Guide will be released in early May, coinciding with an online Discovery Series Gathering designed to support shared reflection and sensemaking. 

To stay connected as these resources are released, leaders are invited to follow the work of the MacRae Centre and the Futuring Hub or join the mailing list for updates and future invitations. 

 This brief is not a conclusion, but an opening. You can also register for a free online event hosted by the MacRae Centre for Christian Faith and Culture. This Future of Innovation: Discovery Series Gathering invites leaders from churches, denominations, parachurch ministries, Christian organizations, and theological institutions into a national act of shared discernment about what the future of innovation may look like.

Register today 

Register for our mailing list for updates, news, and more!

STUDY WITH PURPOSE

If you are interested in pursuing the questions of faith and culture, consider studying with Acadia Divinity College. Explore our program options or speak to our recruitment department today!